Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
● Canadian Science Publishing
All preprints, ranked by how well they match Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences's content profile, based on 18 papers previously published here. The average preprint has a 0.02% match score for this journal, so anything above that is already an above-average fit. Older preprints may already have been published elsewhere.
Moran, P.; Tuttle, V. J.; Bishop, S.; LaVoy, L.
Show abstract
Bycatch impacts on non-target species present significant management problems in diverse fisheries throughout the world. Despite successful efforts to minimize bycatch in US West Coast Pacific Hake fisheries, these impacts remain a concern, particularly for sensitive populations of Chinook Salmon. NOAA Fisheries needed predictive models to estimate proportions of Chinook Salmon Evolutionarily Significant Units (ESUs) expected in bycatch. We used genetic mixture analysis to estimate ESU proportions from at-sea bycatch between 2008 and 2015. Using latitude as a predictor and applying jackknife cross validation, we found Dirichlet regression more accurately estimated abundant ESUs, whereas multinomial logistic regression performed better with rare ESUs. This targeted, ESU-specific approach showed the spatial distribution of sensitive stocks in bycatch and supported NOAAs obligations to forecast impacts on listed ESUs. The overarching goal of this continuing work is to maximize sustainable harvest while protecting threatened and endangered Chinook Salmon ESUs.
Mason, E. T. J.; Riecke, T. V.; Bellquist, L. F.; Pondella, D. J.; Semmens, B. X.
Show abstract
Aggregation-based fisheries are notorious for booms and busts driven by aggregation discovery and subsequent fishing-induced collapse. However, environment-driven sporadic recruitment in some since-protected populations has delayed recovery, suggesting recruitment-limitation may be a key driver of their population dynamics and fishery recovery potential. To glean insight into this dynamic, we focused on an overexploited temperate aggregate spawner (Barred Sand Bass; Paralabrax nebulifer) and leveraged a long-term mark-recapture data set spanning different oceanographic and harvest histories in a custom Bayesian capture-mark-reencounter modeling framework. We coupled this demographic analysis with long-term trends in sea surface temperature, harvest, adult and juvenile densities, and historical accounts in the literature. Our results point to a history of multidecadal windows of fishing opportunity and fishing-induced collapse that were largely driven by sporadic, warm water recruitment events, which may be externally sourced. Nevertheless, we found that environment-driven sporadic recruitment was not a factor impeding recovery following the last collapse, as recruitment remained elevated due to novel, anomalously warm conditions. Despite signs of incipient population recovery, spawning aggregations remain absent, indicating other potential factors (e.g., continued fishing during spawning season, residual Allee effects) have delayed fishery recovery to date. Aggregate spawner populations that are dependent on sporadic recruitment, especially those at their geographic margins, are thus highly susceptible to sudden and potentially extended periods of collapse, making them ill-suited to high CPUE fishing that occurs on spawning grounds. If the goal is to balance the protection of spawning aggregations with long-term fishery sustainability, then limiting aggregation-based fishing during spawning season may be the best insurance policy against collapse and recovery failure.
Anderson, S. C.; Connors, B. M.; English, P. A.; Forrest, R. E.; Haigh, R.; Holt, K. R.
Show abstract
We assembled estimated biomass (B) time series from stock assessments for 24 Pacific Canadian groundfish stocks and modelled average and stock status through 2020 based on biomass relative to each stocks (1) Limit Reference Point (B/LRP), (2) Upper Stock Reference (B/USR), and (3) biomass at maximum sustainable yield (B/BMSY). The overall mean B/LRP in 2020 was 3.2 (95% credible interval [CI]: 2.6-3.9). The overall mean B/USR and B/BMSY in 2020 was 1.5 (95% CI: 1.3-1.9) and 1.4 (95% CI: 1.1-1.7), respectively. Average stock status declined from 1950 to around 2000 and has remained relatively stable since then. The change around 2000 followed the implementation of ITQs (individual transferable quotas) for the trawl fleet and the commencement of the synoptic trawl surveys. As of their last assessment, four stocks (Strait of Georgia Lingcod [Area 4B], coastwide Bocaccio, and inside and outside Quillback Rockfish) had a greater than 5% probability of being below their LRP (i.e., in the " critical zone"); Pacific Cod in Area 3CD had a 4.6% probability. Roughly one-third of stocks had a greater than 1 in 4 chance of being below their USR (i.e., in the " cautious zone"). Conversely, two-thirds of assessed groundfish stocks had a high (>75%) probability of being above the USR (i.e., in the " healthy zone").
Doherty, B.; Johnson, S. D. N.; Benson, A. J.; Cox, S. P.; Cleary, J. S.; Lane, J.
Show abstract
The recovery of marine mammals from historical over-exploitation in the 1970s represents one of the largest changes in trophic structure in the northeast Pacific Ocean over the last century, for which the impacts on key forage species such as Pacific Herring (Clupea pallasii) are poorly understood. This has prompted hypotheses that increasing marine mammal populations are the primary cause for productivity declines for some fish stocks and their lack of recovery to historical abundance levels. In this study, we evaluate such a hypothesis for Pacific Herring by quantifying historical predation rates by key predators including cetaceans (Pacific Humpbacks, Grey Whales), pinnipeds (Stellar Sea Lions, Harbour Seals), and piscivorous fish (Pacific Hake). Predation mortality is quantified via a novel approach that integrates a single-species catch-at-age model with estimates of predator consumption derived from bioenergetic models. We found that predator consumption, largely driven by Humpback Whales, explained increasing Pacific Herring natural mortality rates in recent years and could be used to forecast future mortality. Incorporating higher future natural mortality rates produced higher estimates of current stock status (1.09-1.2B0) based on lower estimates of equilibrium unfished biomass (17.5-20.3 kt). Conversely, models that assumed mortality was more like the historical average had lower stock status (0.63B0) and higher estimates of unfished biomass (32.4 kt). We demonstrate a practical approach for ecosystem modelling that can be used to develop operating model scenarios for management strategy evaluation, improving scientific defensibility by removing an element of analyst choice for future mortality scenarios. We discuss how simpler modifications to single-species model assumptions can be more pragmatic for providing fisheries management advice, while more complex multi-species or ecosystem models might provide more nuanced insights for exploring research questions related to multi-species ecosystems and fisheries interactions.
Atlas, W. I.; Holt, C. A.; Selbie, D. T.; Connors, B. M.; Cox-Rogers, S.; Carr-Harris, C.; Hertz, E.; Moore, J. W.
Show abstract
Management of data-limited populations is a key challenge to the sustainability of fisheries around the world. For example, sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) spawn and rear in many remote coastal watersheds of British Columbia (BC), Canada, making population assessment a challenge. Estimating conservation and management targets for these populations is particularly relevant given their importance to First Nations and commercial fisheries. Most sockeye salmon have obligate lake-rearing as juveniles, and total abundance is typically limited by production in rearing lakes. Although methods have been developed to estimate population capacity based on nursery lake photosynthetic rate (PR) and lake area or volume, they have not yet been widely incorporated into stock-recruit analyses. We tested the value of combining lake-based capacity estimates with traditional stock-recruit based approaches to assess population status using a hierarchical-Bayesian stock-recruit model for 70 populations across coastal BC. This analysis revealed regional variation in sockeye population productivity (Ricker ), with coastal stocks exhibiting lower mean productivity than those in interior watersheds. Using moderately-informative PR estimates of capacity as priors reduced model uncertainty, with a more than five-fold reduction in credible interval width for estimates of conservation benchmarks (e.g. SMAX - spawner abundance at carrying capacity). We estimated that almost half of these remote sockeye stocks are below one commonly applied conservation benchmarks (SMSY), despite substantial reductions in fishing pressure in recent decades. Thus, habitat-based capacity estimates can dramatically reduce scientific uncertainty in model estimates of management targets that underpin sustainable sockeye fisheries. More generally, our analysis reveals opportunities to integrate spatial analyses of habitat characteristics with population models to inform conservation and management of exploited species where population data are limited.
Perry, R. W.; Plumb, J. M.
Show abstract
Restoration of salmon populations in the upper Lewis River Basin depends on a trap-and-haul program owing to the Lewis River Hydroelectric Project (Project) operated by PacifiCorp and Cowlitz PUD (Utilities), which has been a barrier to salmon passage since the 1930s. Thus, sustaining the Coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) population upstream of the Project currently depends on two fundamental factors: (1) the collection of upstream migrating adult Coho salmon at Merwin Dam, the lower most dam within the Project, and transporting them by truck to spawn above Swift Dam, the upper most dam within the Project; and (2) the collection of out-migrating juvenile Coho salmon at the downstream collection facility at Swift Dam for transport and release below the Project. The reintroduction program began once the downstream collection facility at Swift Dam was commissioned in late-2012 with the first year of transport data being collected in 2013. Over the past decade, the Utilities have been collecting data on juvenile outmigrants and adult fish returns at the dams. The need to construct a life cycle model for Lewis River anadromous fish was identified by the Lewis River Aquatic Technical Subgroup, with the understanding that many years (>15) of data collection are needed to adequately measure the life cycle production of coho salmon. Use of past data to construct models could help inform future data collection and provide a framework that can be updated annually to measure trap and haul program performance within a life cycle context (Note: Data are not currently available from PacifiCorp. Contact organization Chris Karchesky for further information). Because Coho salmon can live as long as five years, estimating demographic parameters for Coho salmon populations over their life cycle requires at least 10 or more years of data collection. Over the past decade, PacifiCorp has been collecting data on fish collection efficiency and the numbers of adult and juvenile salmon transported around the Lewis River dams, providing sufficient data to formulate a life cycle model that can guide future data collection efforts and provide preliminary information to resource managers The goal of the statistical life cycle model was to estimate annual production and survival during two critical life-stage transitions (1) the freshwater production from escapement of adults released upstream of Swift Dam, and the collection of downstream migrating juveniles at the passage facility at Swift Dam, and (2) the smolt-to-adult survival from the time of collection at Swift Dam to their return as adults. We used the Beverton-Holt stock-recruitment model to estimate juvenile production from the number of spawners. This approach allowed us to test for density dependence at current spawner abundances while estimating annual productivity, defined as the number of juveniles produced per spawner at low spawner abundance. Productivity was then expressed as a function of the number of juveniles collected and transported downstream of the Project. Because juvenile Fish Collection Efficiency (FCE) directly affects the number of juveniles that survive to continue downstream migration, FCE is a primary determinant of fish production. Consequently, the modeling framework is well suited to evaluate the performance of trap and haul programs within a life cycle context. The objectives of this study were to: (1) gather and collate available data on adult and juvenile Coho salmon at Merwin and Swift dams, (2) quantify adult escapement, juvenile abundance, and the age at outmigration and adult return, (3) describe, formulate, and fit the integrated population model (IPM) to the data, and (4) summarize our findings, identify data gaps, and identify potential opportunities for future studies that could provide information used to improve model estimation and inference. Our key findings were: (1) over and above the number of spawning females, FCE was the primary factor affecting productivity of Coho salmon above Swift Dam, (2) smolt-to-adult return (SAR) rates were relatively high considering that harvest was included in the estimate, averaging about 4.5% and ranging as high as 12.9%, and (3) juvenile capacity upriver of Swift Dam was difficult to estimate due to the limited range in spawning females over the time series of data, suggesting the model may be improved by collecting data at higher spawner abundances. In addition, by including FCE in the model, we estimated that the median pre-collection productivity, defined as the number of juveniles produced per spawner when FCE = 1, was 64 juveniles per spawner. Because this two-stage life cycle model partitions factors that affect fish production in river versus the ocean, the model estimates should help inform fishery managers about the overall role that fish collection at Swift Dam plays in the recovery and sustainability of Lewis River Coho salmon. By providing the model with (1) more years of data, (2) higher numbers of spawning females, and (3) data on age at juvenile migration in relation to age at adult return greater certainty in the estimates of capacity and SAR can be attained. Ultimately, information provided by the model can assist in the evaluation and continued improvement of the current trap and haul program to support anadromous fishes in the Lewis River Basin. O_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=200 HEIGHT=150 SRC="FIGDIR/small/651546v1_ufig1.gif" ALT="Figure 1"> View larger version (106K): org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1fb0bf1org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@cd0576org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@21aa4aorg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@330024_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG C_FIG Cover. Looking upstream on the Lewis River at Merwin Dam, Washington, August, 2024. Photograph by John Plumb, U.S. Geological Survey. Conversion Factors O_TBL View this table: org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@4e45d8org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@cb7879org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@528ad0org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1176401org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@a6bed6_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_TBL C_TBL
Scheuerell, M. D.; Ruff, C. P.; Anderson, J. H.; Beamer, E. M.
Show abstract
O_LIAssessing the degree to which at-risk species are regulated by density dependent versus density independent factors is often complicated by incomplete or biased information. If not addressed in an appropriate manner, errors in the data can affect estimates of population demographics, which may obfuscate the anticipated response of the population to a specific action.\nC_LIO_LIWe developed a Bayesian integrated population model that accounts explicitly for interannual variability in the number of reproducing adults and their age structure, harvest, and environmental conditions. We apply the model to 41 years of data for a population of threatened steelhead trout Oncorhynchus mykiss using freshwater flows, ocean indices, and releases of hatchery-born conspecifics as covariates.\nC_LIO_LIWe found compelling evidence that the population is under strong density dependence, despite being well below its historical population size. In the freshwater portion of the lifecycle, we found a negative relationship between productivity (offspring per parent) and peak winter flows, and a positive relationship with summer flows. We also found a negative relationship between productivity and releases of hatchery conspecifics. In the marine portion of the lifecycle, we found a positive correlation between productivity and the North Pacific Gyre Oscillation. Furthermore, harvest rates on wild fish have been sufficiently low to ensure very little risk of overfishing.\nC_LIO_LISynthesis and applications. The evidence for density dependent population regulation, combined with the substantial loss of juvenile rearing habitat in this river basin, suggests that habitat restoration could benefit this population of at-risk steelhead. Our results also imply that hatchery programs for steelhead need to be considered carefully with respect to habitat availability and recovery goals for wild steelhead. If releases of hatchery steelhead have indeed limited the production potential of wild steelhead, there are likely significant tradeoffs between providing harvest opportunities via hatchery steelhead production, and achieving wild steelhead recovery goals.\nC_LI
Ginez, A. N.; David, S. R.; Lackman, A. R.; Myers, B. J.; Winter, T. J.; Lusardi, R. A.; Rypel, A. L.
Show abstract
There is growing interest in establishing more protective regulations for native fishes historically classified as "rough fish"- a term ascribed to species of low-to-zero perceived commercial value. Yet high-quality population data are lacking for most species and populations, precluding determination of sustainable harvest limits using standard methods. Here, we present an inductive and ecosystem -based approach for comparing and aligning harvest limits of diverse fish species. Our approach centers on the production/biomass (P/B) ratio as the key instrument for gauging sustainable harvest. P/B is the biomass turnover rate in populations and therefore quantifies the return rate of any removed biomass in populations. We extracted and summarized data from existing studies, representing a total of 517 empirical estimates of secondary production, biomass, and P/B ratios. We subsequently developed a highly predictive statistical model (R2 = 0.90), demonstrating P/B is largely a function of maximum age across species. We then developed a separate database on age, growth, and longevity data for most native fishes of interest across the USA. For each species and population, we leveraged the above statistical model to predict and compare mean P/B across species. Results show most native fishes express P/B values similar to, or lower than, traditional game fish species. Accordingly, harvest limits across species groups can be harmonized with those of other managed species. For example, native nongame species like Bigmouth Buffalo Ictiobus cyprinellus and Freshwater Drum Aplodinotus grunniens are long-lived with slow replacement rates that are statistically clustered with those observed in Lake Sturgeon Acipenser fulvescens and trophy Muskellunge Esox masquinongy populations, two popular game fish species. Harvest limits for these nongame species would therefore need to be similarly low for these species to ensure comparable sustainability. To understand broad patterns of harvest limit alignment, we modeled relationships between daily bag limits of managed species and P/B for five test states. Model uniformly showed non-linear trends with high residuals (suggesting excessive bag limits) common for panfish species and low residuals (suggesting overly conservative bag limits) common for trout species. Managers can use the results of this study to estimate harvest limits native fishes.
O'Sullivan, R. J.; Ozerov, M.; Bolstad, G. H.; Gilbey, J.; Jacobsen, J. A.; Erkinaro, J.; Rikardsen, A. H.; Hindar, K.; Aykanat, T.
Show abstract
There is a general paucity of knowledge regards spatial variation in marine resource use for many taxa, even those of high socio-economic importance such as Atlantic salmon. While it is known that the oceans around the Faroe Islands support a salmon feeding ground, the relative use of this feeding ground by different age classes across different stocks remains largely unexplored. Using a combination of genetic stock assignment and run-reconstruction models, we observed a consistent pattern whereby the proportion of multi-sea winter (MSW) salmon for a given reporting group was substantially greater around the Faroes than the MSW proportion for that reporting groups among the prefisheries abundance. Surprisingly, MSW fish from Ireland and UK were as likely to occur around the Faroes as were MSW fish from more north-eastern regions such as the Teno river and the Barents and White Seas. MSW fish from Southern Norway were the most likely to be caught at the Faroes. While 1SW salmon from Ireland and UK as well as from Southern Norway occurred at similar rates around the Faroes, 1SW fish from more north-eastern reporting groups were nearly entirely absent from the same feeding ground. In combination with previous studies that examine the marine distribution of Atlantic salmon, our results strongly indicate that the oceans around the Faroes play host to a predominantly MSW salmon feeding ground and that use of this resource varies both within the age classes of a given stock as well as between different stocks. Furthermore, these results suggest that MSW fish from certain stocks might preferentially undertake migrations to the Faroes. Variation in spatial resource use may help to buffer salmon stocks against localised negative changes in marine conditions.
Gayeski, N.; MacDuffee, M.; Rosenberger, A.; Swanson, D.
Show abstract
Most Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in the northeast Pacific Ocean are harvested in mixed-stock marine fisheries. Here, multiple populations with varying abundance and productivities are encountered. In addition, many of these fisheries generally encounter both mature and immature Chinook. Hence, these fisheries are better described as mixed-stock and "mixed-maturation" (MM) fisheries. Harvest of immature fish can skew the age composition of Chinook populations towards younger, and hence smaller, individuals. Older Chinook are generally larger and contribute disproportionately to the productivity of their populations. We developed an individual-based demographic-genetic model of ocean-type Chinook to evaluate the effects of fisheries that harvest immature Chinook. We then compared those effects to terminal fisheries that harvest only mature fish. Our model provides the ability to assess the benefits of terminal Chinook fisheries to both landed catch and Chinook rebuilding. Recovered populations show a more archetypal age- and sex-structure than contemporary ocean-type Chinook subject to marine mixed-maturation fisheries. In our modeled scenarios of mixed-maturation fisheries, we found that immature Chinook can comprise up to 59% of the total numbers of fish caught, and 47% of the total weight of the catch. If instead, these Chinook were not harvested until they mature and reach terminal fisheries, they would contribute greater biomass to landed catches. These terminal fisheries allow a higher percentage of larger, older Chinook to escape, and would increase the fecundity and productivities of their populations. The benefits of terminal fisheries would accrue to fishers, sustainable wild harvesting, wildlife, and the rebuilding of depleted Chinook runs.
Hyman, A. C.; Collins, A.; Ramsay, C.; Allen, M. S.; Wilms, S.; Barbieri, L.; Frazer, T. K.
Show abstract
Accurate estimation of post-release survival is fundamental to fisheries stock assessment and effective management. Conventional tag-return studies and acoustic telemetry are commonly used to estimate this probability, yet each approach has limitations when applied independently. Using gag (Mycteroperca microlepis) as a case study, we integrated data from a large-scale conventional tagging program and an acoustic telemetry experiment within a discrete-time statistical modeling framework that links relative recapture risk with telemetry-derived fate. This approach enabled estimation of post-release survival across a broad gradient of capture depths representative of recreational fishing conditions. Estimated survival was high in shallow waters ({approx}97%) but declined with increasing capture depth, consistent with depth-related barotrauma. Applying model predictions to depth distributions from the recreational fishery yielded annual and monthly post-release survival probabilities. Annual estimates were consistent with values assumed in recent stock assessments, while monthly values highlighted seasonal patterns potentially relevant for management. This integrated framework advances post-release survival estimation by combining the extensive sample sizes and environmental coverage characteristic of conventional tagging data with the direct fate observations provided by acoustic telemetry, and offers a transferable approach for other highly targeted fisheries.
Mason, E. T. J.; Thompson, A. R.; Semmens, B. X.
Show abstract
Environmental and biological processes acting on fish larvae can drive fishery cohort strength, but predictive ability oftentimes falls short, and larval abundance is generally considered more useful as a proxy for spawning biomass. Under a changing ocean, studies that relate environmental covariates, larval abundance, and fishery recruitment are worthy of continued research, especially in data-limited contexts. We focus on a popular, recreational-only, multispecies saltwater bass fishery (genus Paralabrax) whose population status and recovery potential are uncertain. We used 54 years of ichthyoplankton data (1963-2016) and a species distribution model to 1) deconstruct species-specific standardized indices of larval abundance, 2) test these indices as indicators of adult stock status or predictors of future fishery recruitment, and 3) evaluate spatiotemporal trends in their population dynamics relative to environmental variables. Contrary to expectation, species-specific larval abundance predicted future catch, with recent elevated larval abundance suggesting imminent fishery recovery. Additionally, we identified strong relationships with environmental variables, thereby providing additional tools for predicting fishery recruitment and anticipating population change. Our findings paint a path forward for improving estimates of current and future fishery status under changing natural and anthropogenic influences and the incorporation of ecosystem considerations into fishery management.
Gosselin, J. L.; Sandford, B. P.; O'Brien, C. S.; Buhle, E. R.
Show abstract
Understanding variation in age at maturity is important for endangered species recovery because older, larger adults contribute disproportionately to the next generation. Conditions in early life stages may have underappreciated impacts on age at maturity. Our study objective was to associate adult age of individually tagged wild, spring/summer Chinook Salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) outmigrating from the Snake River (Idaho and Washington, USA) in 1998-2020 with covariates measured during juvenile and subadult stages. We used a hierarchical Bayesian ordinal probit regression model to estimate statistical effects of juvenile body length, seasonal migration timing or river temperature, transported or in-river hydrosystem passage, river flow, and a large-scale ocean index. Results indicated notable carryover effects consistent with underlying biological mechanisms related to growth and development, in which shorter juvenile length and later seasonal migration timing were associated with older adults. These biological and behavioural factors were more important than riverine or marine environmental conditions examined. Our study suggests that managers and decision makers should consider carryover effects from the juvenile life stage on age structure in conjunction with survival.
Ward, E.; English, P. A.; Rooper, C. N.; Ferriss, B. E.; Whitmire, C. E.; Wetzel, C. R.; Barnett, L. A.; Anderson, S. C.; Thorson, J. T.; Johnson, K. F.; Indivero, J.; Markowitz, E. H.
Show abstract
Fisheries management faces challenges due to political, spatial, and ecological complexities, which are further exacerbated by variation or shifts in species distributions. Effective management depends on the ability to integrate fisheries data across political and geographic boundaries. However, such efforts may be hindered by inconsistent data formats, limited data sharing, methodological differences in sampling, and regional governance differences. To address these issues, we introduce the surveyjoin R package, which combines and provides public access to bottom trawl survey data collected by NOAA Fisheries and Fisheries and Oceans Canada in the Northeast Pacific Ocean. This initial database integrates over 3.3 million observations from 14 bottom trawl surveys spanning Alaska, British Columbia, Washington, Oregon, and California from the 1980s to present. This effort standardizes variables such as catch-per-unit-effort (CPUE), haul data, and in-situ measurements of bottom temperature. We demonstrate the utility of this database through three case studies. Our first case study develops a coastwide biomass index for Pacific hake (Merluccius productus) using geostatistical index standardization, comparing results to independent acoustic survey estimates. The second case study examines changes in the spatial distribution of groundfish species across marine heatwave and non-heatwave years, highlighting species-specific and community-level responses to warming events. Our third example applies spatially varying coefficient models to assess sablefish (Anoplopoma fimbria) biomass trends, identifying regional variability in increases in occurrence and biomass. Together, these case studies demonstrate how the surveyjoin R package and database may improve species and ecosystem assessments by providing insights into population trends across geopolitical boundaries. This database and package represent an important step toward offering a scalable framework that can be extended to include additional data types, surveys, and species. By fostering collaboration, transparency, and data-driven decision-making, surveyjoin supports international efforts to sustainably manage shared marine resources under dynamic environmental conditions.
Trijoulet, V.; Berg, C. W.; Sparrevohn, C. R.; Nielsen, A.; Pastoors, M. A.; Mosegaard, H.
Show abstract
In the Northeast Atlantic, advice for many fish stocks follows the ICES MSY approach, where a zero catch will be recommended if the stock is below its limit reference point, Blim, and cannot rebuild in the short-term. How-ever, zero catch advice are rarely implemented by managers. This study used medium-term stochastic forecasts with harvest control rules (HCRs) to investigate the consequences of allowing reduced fishing below Blim. We applied the method to western Baltic herring and North Sea cod, two contrasting species currently estimated below Blim. We show that the minimum rebuilding probability of 95% required by the MSY approach could be impossible to reach in the short-to medium-term. When this is the case, a lower probability may need to be considered instead in the short-term. Recruitment is the largest source of uncertainty in stock response to management, and can exceed differences between HCRs. Reference points should be estimated in accordance with current recruitment levels if they are to be used for short-term advice or as realistic rebuilding targets. For both stocks, it is possible to keep fishing at reduced levels for similar cumulative catch, SSB and risk on the stock in the medium-term compared to no catch below Blim. Medium-term trade-offs between stock conservation and fisheries considerations may be needed when fishery closure cannot be implemented in practice.
Mildenberger, T.; Berg, C. W.; Kokkalis, A.; Hordyk, A. R.; Wetzel, C.; Jacobsen, N. S.; Punt, A. E.; Nielsen, J. R.
Show abstract
The precautionary approach to fisheries management advocates for risk-averse management strategies that include biological reference points as well as decision rules and account for scientific uncertainty. In this regard, two approaches have been recommended: (i) harvest control rules (HCRs) with threshold reference points to safeguard against low stock biomass, and (ii) the P* method, a probability-based HCR that reduces the catch limit as a function of scientific uncertainty (i.e. process, model, and observation uncertainty). This study compares the effectiveness of these precautionary approaches in recovering over-exploited fish stocks with various life-history traits and under a wide range of levels of scientific uncertainty. We use management strategy evaluation based on a stochastic, age-based operating model with quarterly time steps and a stochastic surplus production model. The results show that the most effective HCR includes both a biomass threshold as well as the P* method, and leads to high and stable long-term yield with a decreased risk of low stock biomass. For highly dynamics stocks, management strategies that aim for higher biomass targets than the traditionally used BMSY result in higher long-term yield. This study makes the case for probability-based HCRs by demonstrating their benefit over deterministic HCRs and provides a list of recommendations regarding their definition and implementation.
Okamura, H.; Ichinokawa, M.; Hilborn, R.
Show abstract
Fisheries management in Japan is currently at a turning point. MSY based reference points have historically been rejected because of impacts on the fishing industry that would result from their adoption. We propose and evaluate a new harvest control rule (HCR) that uses the biological reference points based on sustainable yield from the stochastic hockey-stick stock recruitment relationship. Management strategy evaluation simulations conditioned on data from Japanese stocks demonstrate that the new HCR avoided recruitment overfishing while providing stable and near maximum catch. The new HCR outperformed Japans traditional HCR in terms of conservation, and it outperformed an alternative HCR which is widely used around the world in terms of initial catch reduction and future catch variation. For forecasting and hindcasting simulations, the new HCR showed considerable improvements over traditional HCRs in terms of biomass and catch. This new management procedure can improve the current and future status of many overfished stocks in Japan as well as increase economic efficiency and better protect ecosystems.
Regular, P. M.; Koen-Alonso, M.; Morgan, M. J.; Pepin, P.; Rideout, R. M.
Show abstract
Carrying capacity is a fundamental concept in ecology that has inspired the development and application of a broad range of population models. In the context of fisheries science, production models have been employed globally to calculate carrying capacity and guide the sustainable use of fish populations. Production models have, however, been criticized for failing to account for species interactions and environmental effects. We aim to fill some of these gaps by introducing a novel state-space multispecies production model. We apply our extended model to commercially important demersal fish species off the east coast of Canada to assess its ability to reveal species interactions and the relative impacts of fishing and environmental effects. Our results indicate that accounting for species interactions increases the accuracy of biomass estimates for species within a community. The model also revealed strongly correlated process deviations, unrelated to fishing or density-dependent effects, which unexpectidly indicates that widespread collapses were primarily driven by a common environmental driver rather than fishing. Such inferences indicate that this may be a promising avenue for producing more holistic and accurate assessments for multiple species with relatively minimal data requirements (time-series of landings and fisheries-independent indices). Finally, this approach may serve as a stepping stone towards an ecosystem-based approach to fisheries management.
Walter, J. A.; Singer, G. P.; Reuman, D. C.; Colborne, S. F.; Sheppard, L. W.; O'Donnell, D. R.; Coombs, N.; Johnston, M.; Miller, E. A.; Steel, A. E.; Kelly, J. T.; Fangue, N. A.; Rypel, A. L.
Show abstract
Understanding intraspecific variation in habitat use, particularly of long-lived fishes across multiple life history stages, is core to improved conservation management. Here, we present results from a synthesis of acoustic telemetry data for large juvenile and adult white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus) from 2010 to 2017 in the San Francisco Estuary and Sacramento River ecosystems. We focused primarily on uncovering spatial patterns of inferred habitat occupancy across life stages, and on linking habitat use to population threats. We found substantial differences in habitat use across individuals and over time that was related to fish age class. However, differences in habitat use were not explained by fish sex or water year flow conditions. We estimated an index of angling exposure, which showed that fish entering reproductive maturity, which historically were of harvestable size, were detected less often than other sizes in areas with high angler pressure, suggesting possible behavioral avoidance of areas of high angler pressure. Additionally, we used historical data to evaluate potential exposure of white sturgeon to a severe red tide event in late summer 2022. We found that >50% of reproductive-age fish may have been residing in areas affected by the red tide. Future monitoring and management of white sturgeon might benefit from examining multiple phases of white sturgeon life history. For example, additional tracking studies could improve understanding of juvenile habitat use, adult survival rates, patterns of anadromy, and cross-basin habitat utilization.
Munaweera, I.; Harris, L. N.; Moore, J.-S.; Tallman, R. F.; Gilbert, M.; Fisk, A. T.; Else, B. G. T.; Ahmed, M. M. M.; Gillis, D. M.; Muthukumarana, S.
Show abstract
Hierarchical modelling is frequently used to model ecological processes because of its ability to handle complex ecological phenomena by decomposing them into naturally explainable sub-models. Hierarchical Bayesian approaches have gained widespread use in health, social, and environmental sciences, including in the estimation of demo-graphic parameters such as survival. In this study, we combine Bayesian hierarchical models with acoustic telemetry data to estimate survival probabilities for high-latitude populations of an anadromous salmonid, the Arctic char (Salvelinus alpinus), while in-corporating environmental and biological covariates to assess their impact on survival. The model we present here can also account for temporally varying detection probabilities due to changes to the acoustic receiver array design and seasonal variation in the detection probabilities related to environmental conditions (e.g., ice vs. no ice). As previously documented in this species, survival was high (> 0.87) and we found that the covariates pertaining to sea ice coverage and Fultons condition factor impacted the survival probabilities. Contrary to our expectations, high-condition fish had lower survival rates. Survival was also considerably lower during the summer (open-water) compared to winter (ice-covered) seasons. While the biological explanations and implications of these findings require further exploration, they nonetheless demonstrate the utility of this approach. Specifically, we present a hierarchical Bayesian model that can consider environmental and biological covariates while accounting for varying detection probabilities, a major concern of acoustic telemetry studies. The model can be easily adapted for other taxa with similar life histories where mark recapture data are available and can be extended to include additional environmental (e.g., salinity) and biological parameters (e.g., sex).